This is "About the Way"?
This is an old point. Responses to it are pretty much predictable. Either it's an actual account of something that happened to that effect, or it isn't even close to anything that happened.
If it isn't close to anything that happened, then there's nothing else to discuss, the account is unreliable, the book is unreliable, and the codex is unreliable. This isn't news to anyone- anyone who says this already was saying those.
If it's an actual account, we have to take into account the ability of the then-contemporary readers and listeners to make sense of things. (That's clear no matter WHO wrote it.) I can easily posit that an All- Mighty God could pause the Earth and suspend all consequences, since He would have the power to do so. However, if asked my opinion, I think it's more likely that an All-Mighty God would produce the effect, and let the puny people understand it their way without any need to educate them to 21st century scientific understanding. I would posit that all planets, stars, etc continued as normal, and that what was altered was the light hitting the Earth. An All-Mighty God could certainly do so, which would lengthen, shorten, or abruptly begin or end a day.
Granted, this would certainly be on the high end of fantastic for a miracle, but that's not proof of anything by itself. If there is an All-Mighty God, He COULD do exactly this, and if there wasn't, then the account was simply cooked.
How would we know which was the answer? Everyone's answer to that is that this was a closed issue before they reached these verses. Either they already believed or they already dis-believed. It goes to the general body of evidence long before it gets here.